Epic Failure: Curing and Brining Olives
As with many things I write about, I have no idea what possessed me to believe that I should cure olives. Isn't our tiny house and our tiny kitchen already stuffed with my experiments (in progress now: plum wine, hard cider, salted liver)?
Olives weren't even premeditated. I saw them in the produce section looking kind of sickly. The conversation with myself went something like this:
Oh look! Olives! I've never done olives before. I wonder how hard they are. I mean, how hard can they be? Someone's been making them for hundreds of years without technology, surely I can figure it out. And if they don't go well...well, I better just buy a pound.
I got the pound home, looked them over, and went online. I was a little intimidated by the lye-curing technique - only because I was unsure about how safe ingesting lye would be, even the 'it's safe to eat' variety. I'd seen on a few posts the steps for water curing and I decided I'd try that. Figured if it was going to fail, at least I wouldn't be changing lye-water daily. Water curing involves rinsing the olives daily (or more often) until the bitterness is done, something I'd do and not lose sleep if the results went south.
About a week or two later, I saw olive curing/brining posts from both Michael Ruhlman and Hank Shaw, and I was relieved to think I wouldn't be finishing the process alone. With their guidance, I knew I'd make it.
The olives water cured for about 4 weeks. That was how long it took to pull out the bitterness. After that, I brined them in a salty/vinegary solution with some bay leaves and orange and lemon zest. They sat in that solution for about a month. Things were looking good. I pulled them out for a taste test and...GAG! The bitterness was all back again. I thought I had gotten all of it out but it was definitely still there - so I tossed the vinegar solution and in desperation put the olives back in a water cure to try to leech out the bitter again.
I had a second set of olives going at the same time, and those were a few weeks behind the first. After they were all abandoned over a holiday weekend, I came home to find them deep in the throes of a stinky mold, the water completely cloudy and the flesh falling from the pits. That was it, enough. I tossed them in the yard waste bin and vowed to try the lye approach next time. If there's a next time.
More Info
Hank Shaw's Honest Food post on How to Cure Green Olives
Michael Ruhlman's post on How to Cure Olives
Bittman's post from the NYTimes on marinating olives
A fun video of Jose Andres and marinated olives from Savory.tv














































